2006 ODAC Board of Directors Meeting
May 22-24 –
Attendance:
Curt Kendall
Jean Willi
Dave King Eastern
Mennonite
JP Barfield Emory
& Henry
Bev Hatch Emory
& Henry
Marion Kirby
Stephanie Flamini
Joe Bush Hampden-Sydney
Dr. Walter Bortz Hampden-Sydney
Lynda Calkins Hollins
Carleen Overacker Hollins
Jack Toms
Denis Kanach Randolph-Macon
Jeff Burns Randolph-Macon
Carroll LaHaye Randolph-Macon
Val Cushman R-M
Woman’s
Heather Somers R-M
Woman’s
Kevin Porterfield R-M
Woman’s
Scott Allison
Kelly Morrison Sweet
Briar
Sonny Travis
Joanne Renn Virginia
Wesleyan
Mike Walsh Washington
and Lee
Cinda Rankin Washington
and Lee
Jan Hathorn Washington
and Lee
Brad Bankston ODAC
Office
Chris Kilcoyne ODAC
Office
The meeting was called to order by President Curt Kendall at
2:05pm.
Val Cushman notified the ADs that former RMWC athletics
director Emily Ryals had passed away. The memorial service would be held later
in the week (Thursday 2pm).
Approval of 2005 Meeting Minutes
The minutes from the spring and fall 2005 meetings were
moved and approved.
Commissioner Evaluation
President Curt Kendall distributed packages to each AD. The
package included a comprehensive way to submit additional data to the Executive
Committee when it reviews the conference commissioner. The Board was encouraged
to offer items for 2006-07 conference goals and asked to return the review by
June 9th.
Presidential Report
Dr. Walter Bortz was present for the meeting. There was no
formal report from the presidents.
Dr. Ken Garren (
Standing Committees
Awards (Heather Somers)
The committee
discussed several items referred to it following the fall meeting. Heather
Somers reported the committee’s thoughts on the request to create a scoring
leader award in men’s soccer. The committee will ask the committee if it prefers
to rename the POY award for RMC’s Helmut Werner.
Commissioner
Bankston was asked to work with Jostens on a redesign of the conference
Scholar-athlete award.
The
committee is planning recognition for ODAC Administrative Assistant Mary Jane
Esperti. The committee would like feedback/suggestions from the members. The
ceremony will most likely be held during the ODAC Basketball Tournament in
February 2007.
Calendar and Site Committee (Jeff
Burns)
Agreed that
the 2006 Fall Directors Meeting will be held on the Hampden-Sydney campus Dec.
4-5.
Emory &
Henry will be the next in line to host the meeting in December 2007.
Championships and Games Committee
(Mike Walsh)
The
committee’s focus surrounded the upcoming combined ODAC basketball tournament
in February 2007. There were several items that needed a decision prior to the
end of the academic year. The final actions for the 2007 Tournament can be
found below:
·
The
basketball tournament will follow a Thursday-Sunday format. The men will begin
play on Thursday. The women quarterfinals will be held on Friday. Semifinals
scheduled for Saturday and Sunday championships at 1&3. (PASSED – unanimous)
·
Banquets
will be held on Wednesday night (men) beginning at 6:30. The women’s banquet
will take place Thursday evening (within the 5-6pm window). All teams in the
conference should be encouraged to attend the banquets (PASSED – unanimous)
The
committee also scheduled a time during the retreat to draw the ODAC 2006-07
tiebreaker lots. The new lots can be found below:
School BB MBB WBB FB FHC MLX WLX MSOC WSOC SB VB
Catholic x x x 1 x x x x x x x
Eastern Mennonite 1 7 3 x 6 x x 10 10 10 3
Emory & Henry 6 3 9 3 x x x 4 3 5 2
Hampden-Sydney 7 6 x 5 x 1 x 2 x x x
Hollins x x 6 x x x 3 x 8 x x
Randolph-Macon 10 9 4 2 3 6 7 8 11 9 8
R-M Woman’s x x 10 x 4 x x x 6 1 5
Sweet Briar x x x x 9 x 5 x 12 7 7
Washington
and Lee 4 2 2 7 1 5 2 3 5 x 11
Constitution and Manual
No report
Eligibility
No report
Membership
No report
Officiating Committee (Joe Bush)
Commissioner
Bankston discussed the items facing the officiating committee in the next year.
The main focus will be determining 2007-2010 officials’ fees for the sports
assigned within the ODAC. Rates from comparable leagues were reviewed and a
draft proposal for the upcoming rates was distributed.
Several
members expressed concern about the quality of the conference officials
especially in the sports of field hockey, women’s lacrosse and basketball. The
commissioner was asked to continue a focus on improving the women’s lacrosse
officials association. Efforts should be made to identify a time to host a
clinic to support the development of officials in the area.
The
committee members agreed to host a joint meeting/phone conference with the
conference supervisors in the late summer. Commissioner Bankston will work to
schedule the event in August.
League Scheduling Committee (Jean
Willi)
Members
expressed concern over the men’s lacrosse schedule – the issues surrounding
mid-week non-conference games and the focus on a weighted weekend conference
schedule.
The
committee focused on the women’s basketball schedule and helping the committees
sort through conflict weekends. It recommended that the ADs not focus on
combined schedules in the future. A large majority of the conference members
are not planning to take advantage of the combo travel opportunities.
The meeting
was adjourned until Tuesday morning.
Tuesday, May 23
The meeting
was called to order by President Curt Kendall at 8am.
The
conference welcomed several guests to the meeting for special presentations.
NCAA Membership Services
Mira
Fronczek from the NCAA Office was the first to present. Ms. Fronczek is the
conference’s membership services contact and has served in that position for
over 10 years. Ms. Colman was asked to discuss several items for the ADs
including an introduction to the new legislation following the 2006 NCAA
Convention and a brief review of the NCAA’s Legislative Services Database
(LSDBi).
Ms. Fronczek
was commended by the Board for her commitment to the conference over the past
10 years. Ms. Fronczek will no longer serve the conference. Changes in the
national office will dedicate individuals to DIII. Ms. Fronczek will not be one
of those people on the staff. Matthew Banker will replace her in the 2006-07
academic year – effective July 1.
Penn
Jack
Pennington President and CEO of Penn Atlantic, Inc. was introduced to the
Board. Mr. Pennington proceeded with a prepared presentation on Penn Atlantic
and its capabilities to web stream numerous conference games and championship
events. Mr. Pennington demoed his product and took questions from the members.
The conference has worked with Penn Atlantic numerous times in 2005-06 –
including the conference semifinals and finals of the M&W Basketball
Tournaments.
After his
presentation Commissioner Bankston was asked to work with Penn Atlantic in
2006-07 to provide games across the league – some in each season. Additional
information for the Board will come in 2006-07.
Sport Committee Reports:
Athletic Training (JP Barfield)
There were
no formal agenda items for consideration with the exception of the committee’s
request to meet via conference call. The committee was concerned about finding
a time to get together because they are in season at all times. It is
understood that the trainers and SIDs are two year-round positions in the
conference. The proposal passed 11Y, 2N – AGREED FOR ONE-YEAR TRIAL.
The trainers also offered that the ADs explore
the possibility of having
The
commissioner was asked to review with several campus risk managers and report
back to the Board when complete.
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Baseball (Mike Walsh)
The
committee had only one recommendation. Mr. Walsh alerted the Board of a
possible request from the coaches suggesting an eight-team tournament. Concerns
over available facilities and the importance of the regular season were brought
forward.
In addition
– the committee will explore the halted game rule following a game earlier in
the season called for darkness.
Recommendation
to host the 2007 ODAC Baseball Tournament April 26th-29th
at Lynchburg City Stadium. (PASSED – DATE APPROVED 10Y, 0N, 3Abstin – ASK THAT
THE COMMISSIONER CONTACT
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Equestrian (Lynda Calkins)
Recommendation
to move championship date from third week in April to first Friday in April,
2007. (PASSED – 5Y, 0N, 8Abstin NOTING THAT W&L WILL HOLD EXAMS THAT WEEK.
W&L WILL REPORT BACK TO THE GROUP IN THE EVENT CONFLICT CANNOT BE RESOLVED
ON CAMPUS. IF NEEDED, THE COACHES WILL BE CONTACTED TO REVIEW FOR ANOTHER
POSSIBLE DATE).
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Golf (Jeff Burns)
The
committee had numerous items for consideration. Mr. Burns brought additional
items to the attention of the Board including the committee’s voting
procedures, honorable mention selections and proposed 2006-07 tournaments. The
committee had three specific recommendations.
·
Change
in all-conference voting – coaches voting for their own players. (PASSED –
UNANIMOUS)
·
Adopt
the recommended tournaments for 2006-07 season. (PASSED – UNANIMOUS)
·
Recommend
a 54-hole ODAC Tournament without a practice-round. The tournament would take no more than the
three days total. Poplar Grove will allow each team to come in and play a
practice round prior to the two-week pre-tournament window. (PASSED – 8Y, 1N, 4
ABSTIN). There were concerns with including no practice round in the three-day
count. Several ADs were concerned with the possible pressures having
student-athletes traveling to the championship site on their own prior to the
tournament.
Men’s Lacrosse (Denis Kanach)
Mr. Kanach
relayed the discussion items from the committee meeting including a lengthy
dialogue on conference scheduling. The coaches asked that the league scheduling
committee consider a five-week condensed conference schedule in 2008.
The report
was accepted.
Softball (Dave King)
The
committee was concerned with mid-week scheduling in the league. The coaches
requested that the ADs review the procedure and asked if the ADs would consider
relaxing some appeal restrictions in the future.
The halted
game rule was brought forward. Numerous Board members and softball coaches
expressed concern over the potential cost factor having to return to complete a
game that has little or no affect on the final standings. Cost factors were
also discussed – including the thought of having to stay overnight to complete
a game during the regular season possibly affecting class attendance as well.
Extensive
discussion ensued surrounding the coaches’ request to move the conference
tournament from the Moyer Sports Complex in
·
Request
to move the ODAC Softball Tournament to the Virginia Sports Complex from the
James I. Moyer Sports Complex in
·
Alternative
proposal (Dave King, EMU) – Request that the ODAC softball tournament be held
at the Moyer Sports Complex in 2007 and 2008 and the Commissioner research
additional sites to build a state-wide rotation beginning in 2009 with a report
made at the spring 2008 coaches meeting – possibly as early as the 2007 coaches
and ADs meeting. (PASSED – 9Y, 1N, 3 Abstin)
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Sports Information Directors (Brad
Bankston)
The board
discussed the proposal to change the scholar-athlete award per sport to include
sophomores. The SID justification for the change involved the number of
qualified candidates in certain sports.
The proposal
to add sophomores to the list of student-athletes eligible for the sport-by-sport
Scholar-Athlete awards was moved. It passed (8Y, 5N, 0 Abstin).
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Swimming (Lynda Calkins)
The report
was accepted. The coaches had no recommendations for the Board to consider.
Men’s Tennis (Joe Bush)
In response
to an NCAA move requiring AQs in men’s tennis, the men’s tennis committee
focused its meeting on changing in tournament format in 2008. The ADs
considered various problems associated with the tournament change including
site conflicts and the choices dual coaches would have to make while covering
both events held on the same weekend.
Several
Board members were in favor of the move and encouraged the consideration of a men’s
tennis tournament later in April. The current date formula calls for the
tournament championship in mid-April. The season is viewed by several
conference members as too short.
The recommendation
to change the tournament format to a dual team format passed. (10Y, 0N, 3Abstin)
The Board referred the planning details (site, time, dates) back to the
committee for further discussion noting numerous conflicts including the
women’s tournament on the same weekend, the length of the men’s tennis season,
dual coaches, etc.
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Track and Field (Jack Toms)
·
The
committee would like to have the indoor championship on a Saturday at
·
Change
the order of the running events at outdoor track championship meet – 100m
trials followed by 100m/110m hurdles (women & men) followed by 200m trials
and a break – then continue current schedule. (PASSED – unanimous)
·
Request
to use standard medals from one company (Crown Awards). Host would purchase
each year (top 3 in each event including top 14 in cross country). (PASSED – unanimous)
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
Women’s Lacrosse (Jan Hathorn)
The women’s
lacrosse report was reordered in the agenda to accommodate Jan Hathorn’s
schedule.
The Board’s
focus remained on the coaches’ request for additional requirements on the
conference officiating association. Several of the coaches’ recommendations
considered changes to the conference fee structure and concerns about travel
costs.
Several Board
members proposed a move back to two-person officiating if the conference cannot
solve the supply issue within the league association.
Commissioner
Bankston agreed to work with league assignor Dee McDonough and develop ways to
address the number of qualified officials available to the league.
The coaches’
recommendations considered can be found below:
·
Assignor
should assign the higher rated officials to ODAC games – asking that the
coaches have the schedules to the assignor prior to September 1st of
each academic year. (PASSED – 10Y, 0N, 3Abstin)
·
The
officials will be assigned and paid relative to their US Lax/NCAA lacrosse
rating – including a travel reimbursement – mileage (figure to be determined).
(PASSED – 10Y, 0N, 3Abstin)
·
Assignor
should align itself with one board – preferably the
The
remainder of the report was accepted.
The meeting
was adjourned Tuesday at 5pm
Wednesday, May 24
The meeting
was called to order at 8:30am by President Kendall.
Jamestown 2007
Charles
Reusing of Jamestown 2007 visited with league members. Mr. Reusing walked
conference members through the college athletics marketing plan proposed by
Commissioners Report
Commissioner
Bankston started the business portion of the meeting with his semi-annual
commissioner’s report.
Traditionally
the spring report begins with conference staff reviews. Board members accepted
Mr. Bankston’s reviews and expressed concern about the direction of the women’s
lax and field hockey associations. Mr. Bankston was asked to review the
procedures with current assignor Dee McDonough and look for ways to improve the
process in 2007 and beyond.
Spring
championship hosting in the conference went very well in 2006. Commissioner
Bankston complimented all the schools for their hard work and dedication to the
league. Congratulations were passed to
those who advanced to NCAA play and achieved national honors – including Va
Wesleyan’s Men’s Basketball NCAA title and W&L’s runner-up finish in
women’s tennis.
Commissioner
Bankston called the Board’s attention to a new program planned for August 2006.
The conference will sponsor a new coaches’ seminar session. A variety of dates
were discussed for the meeting – and August 9th was the date chosen.
Mr. Bankston asked if ADs interested in presenting to the group let him know as
soon as possible so the conference office could create the agenda and timeline
for the meeting.
Old Business
Long-Range Planning
The Board
reviewed the information prepared by JP Barfield (E&H) and a school intern
in the spring semester. Mr. Barfield explained the information contained in the
folder. The Board agreed for the long-range planning committee to receive a
copy of the report and review it prior to formal discussion by the entire
Board. The planning committee will review the materials and meet prior to the
May 2007 meeting to have a formal plan for the Board’s review.
The league
members commended Mr. Barfield and E&H intern David Chewning for their hard
work on the project.
Sportsmanship (Joanne Renn and Curt
Kendall)
The
conference reviewed the individual school progress on the sportsmanship issue.
League members discussed their individual focus on campus and continued
challenges presented across the conoference and Division III.
Commissioner
Bankston indicated that the DIII Commissioner’s association had proposed a sportsmanship
plan which was evaluated by the NCAA office and supported for a division-wide
initiative in 2006-07. Additional information on the plan was emailed to the
ADs.
The conference
adopted the DIII Commissioners’ Sportsmanship Plan in principle with schools
having the ability to incorporate pieces of the plan immediately into their
campus policies. The conference sportsmanship committee will convene in the
fall to review the entire plan and report back to the Board at the 2006
December meeting. It was noted that the Commissioner should attend the annual
DIII Commissioners’ Meeting and indicate the ODAC’s commitment to the proposed
plan. (Passed – unanimous).
Joe Bush
presented the question to the Board – Should we continue with pass lists in the
2006-07 academic year? Mr. Bush cited several instances at HSC when the
opponent did not have a pass list which in turn caused unnecessary problems for
games management and parents/friends visiting to see a contest.
Additional
concerns were raised in relation to the number of people admitted per
student-athlete. Curt Kendall proposed that a professional courtesy should be
two admissions per student-athlete. The group agreed to move forward with
policy and maintain the current pass list procedure in 2006-07.
New Business
Integration institute
Commissioner
Bankston reviewed the schedule of events for the upcoming ODAC Integration
Institute slated for May 30-31 at
NCAA Management Council Update
Val Cushman,
vice-chair of the DIII Management Council, addressed the group. She covered
various items of national interest including the subject of DIII year-round
drug testing, budget philosophy, championship issues and financial aid.
She called
attention to the financial aid audit and additional pieces of potential
legislation for the 2007 convention. The subject of male practice players was a
hot topic nationally and it also received some discussion within the league
meeting.
NCAA Woman of the Year
Val Cushman
and Brad Bankston called the members’ attention to a change in NCAA policy.
Beginning in June 2006, the nominees for the NCAA Woman of the Year will come
from conference offices. The change in the procedure prompted the national
office to create a plan for leagues to review. Ms. Cushman stated that the
winner of the 2006 Marge Berkley award should be the nominee in 2006. The Board
agreed that the awards committee should review this policy prior to the 2007
selections to determine the best course of action with the 2007 NCAA
nomination.
DIII Conference Grant Program
The league
members reviewed the conference plan for the Tier I, II and III monies.
Conference members asked that the Executive Committee review the funds and
propose a plan to the membership prior to the final deadline for grant
submission in late June.
Commissioner Cup Presentations
Washington
and Lee received all three conference Commissioner Cups including the Dan
Wooldridge award for overall athletic department performance.
Scholar-Athlete Voting
The league’s
top two scholar-athletes were selected. Randolph-Macon’s Megan Silva and
Eastern Mennonite’s Joel Shank were the 2005-06 award recipients.
Nominating Committee Report
Val Cushman
presented the nominating committee report.
The
committee thanked Curt Kendall for his service to the league and proposed Kelly
Morrison (Sweet Briar) for the position of president-elect. Mike Walsh (Washington
and Lee) would assume the role as president on July 1. The report was moved and
accepted by a unanimous vote.
The meeting
was adjourned at 12:29pm